The Ranked Guide

Best Cleansing Balms and Makeup Removers 2027

Ten premium cleansing balms and oils ranked for 2027 on melt, rinse and formula honesty, led by the Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm, with fragrance free and double cleanse picks for every routine.

Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm open jar showing the yellow balm texture — Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm: ranked firstBest Cleansing Balms and Makeup Removers 2027

No. 1

Top Picks at a Glance

The whole ranking on one page: the verdict, the headline specification and the tier for every pick.

Rank	Product	The verdict, in one line	Format	Tier	Buy
1	Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing BalmBest Overall	The spa ritual balm that turns from balm to oil to milk	Solid balm in a jar	luxury	View on Amazon
2	Clinique Take The Day Off Cleansing BalmBest Fragrance Free Balm	The fragrance free benchmark every other balm gets measured against	Solid balm in a jar	premium	View on Amazon
3	Farmacy Green Clean Makeup Removing Cleansing BalmBest for Heavy Makeup Days	The sorbet textured meltaway balm with a farm grown greens blend	Sorbet texture balm in a jar, spatula included	premium	View on Amazon
4	Elemis Pro-Collagen Naked Cleansing BalmBest Unscented Luxury Balm	The Elemis ritual with the aromatic blend taken out	Solid balm in a jar	luxury	View on Amazon
5	Dermalogica PreCleanse Cleansing OilBest Oil for Double Cleansing	The professional first step built for a true double cleanse	Liquid cleansing oil in a pump bottle	premium	View on Amazon
6	Tatcha Pure One Step Camellia Cleansing OilBest Luxury Cleansing Oil	A single step Japanese camellia oil that rinses to a milk	Liquid cleansing oil in a bottle	luxury	View on Amazon
7	Caudalie Vinoclean Makeup Removing Cleansing OilBest Plant Oil Blend	A 100 percent natural origin oil blend built on grape seed and almond	Liquid cleansing oil in a pump bottle	premium	View on Amazon
8	Eve Lom Cleanser, The Original Balm CleanserBest Ritual Balm	The original balm ritual, muslin cloth and all	Balm cleanser in a jar, muslin cloth included	prestige	View on Amazon
9	IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Makeup 3-in-1 Makeup Melting Cleansing BalmBest Multitasking Balm	The balm that also clocks in as a cleanser and a hydrating mask	Balm in a jar, also used as a short mask	premium	View on Amazon
10	Estee Lauder Advanced Night Cleansing BalmBest Night Ritual Balm	A buttery night balm with a 25 percent safflower oil infusion	Buttery balm in a jar	luxury	View on Amazon

The edit in motion: every product in this guide, in ranked order.The Showcase

No. 2

The Ranking in Full

10 premium listings, in the order we would buy them - each with its specification, its strengths and its honest limitations.

No. 1Best Overallluxury tier

Premium listing verified: Official Elemis listing on Amazon under ELEMIS Skincare with From ELEMIS storefront attribution; brand is a long standing Premium Beauty presence on Amazon

Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm

The spa ritual balm that turns from balm to oil to milk

It is the most complete package in the set: a mineral oil free balm built on Padina Pavonica, starflower, elderberry and Optimega oils that moves through three textures, removes long wear makeup in the massage, and can stay on as a ten minute mask. If scent is welcome in your routine, this is the jar the others are compared to.

The specification

Format: Solid balm in a jar
Size: 100 g / 3.5 oz
Key ingredients: Padina Pavonica, starflower oil, elderberry oil, Optimega oil, rose and mimosa waxes
Texture change: Balm to oil to cleansing milk
Formula note: Mineral oil free; nine essential oils including lavender, chamomile and eucalyptus

Strengths

Three texture journey in one jar: nourishing balm, cleansing oil, then a hydrating milk on contact with water
Padina Pavonica algae with starflower, elderberry and Optimega oils in a mineral oil free base
Doubles as a ten minute treatment mask per the brand directions, which few rivals in this set offer

Limitations

Strong aromatic profile from lavender, chamomile, eucalyptus and seven other essential oils will not suit scent sensitive users
Jar format with no spatula mentioned in the listing directions, so fingers do the scooping
Balm can arrive shifted or partly melted in warm transit because of its low melting point, as the brand itself notes

What owners report

In praise

The spa like scent and the slow melt are the recurring delight, owners describe the cleanse itself as the relaxing part of the evening
Long wear foundation and mascara are widely reported to dissolve without rubbing or a second pass
Skin feeling soft and calm afterwards, rather than tight, comes up again and again from dry skin owners

With reservations

The fragrance is polarising, a minority find the essential oil blend too strong near the eyes
Warm weather shipping can leave the surface uneven or oily looking on arrival
Some owners wish a cloth or spatula were still included in the box

Suits

Anyone who wants the full evening ritual: a rich balm that rewards a slow massage and leaves dry or mature feeling skin soft rather than stripped

Skip if

You avoid fragrance in skincare. The original formula carries a pronounced blend of nine essential oils, so choose the Naked version or Clinique instead

View on Amazon See Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm on Amazon

No. 2Best Fragrance Free Balmpremium tier

Premium listing verified: Official Clinique listing on Amazon with From Clinique storefront attribution; manufacturer Clinique Laboratories, LLC as printed in the product details

Clinique Take The Day Off Cleansing Balm

The fragrance free benchmark every other balm gets measured against

The disciplined alternative. A safflower based balm to oil with a published removal figure above 95 percent for makeup, sunscreen and pollutants, 100 percent fragrance free and ophthalmologist tested as printed. It rinses completely clean, which is exactly what sensitive eyes and reactive skin ask of a first cleanse.

The specification

Format: Solid balm in a jar
Size: 125 ml / 3.8 oz
Key ingredients: Safflower seed oil, caprylic/capric triglyceride, tocopherol
Texture change: Solid balm to silky oil
Formula note: 100 percent fragrance free; allergy tested, dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested as published

Strengths

100 percent fragrance free and allergy tested, with dermatologist and ophthalmologist testing as published by the brand
Safflower seed oil base transforms from a solid balm to a silky oil and rinses off completely, per the listing
Brand published removal figure of over 95 percent of face makeup, sunscreen and pollutants

Limitations

No aromatic payoff at all, which ritual lovers may find clinical
Short, functional ingredient list means no headline botanical oils for those who shop by actives
Solid texture is firmer than the Elemis or Farmacy balms, so it needs a few seconds of palm warmth before it spreads

What owners report

In praise

Owners with sensitive eyes repeatedly praise that it removes eye makeup without stinging or clouding
The clean rinse with no filmy residue is the most consistent compliment
Makeup artists and heavy sunscreen wearers value how predictably it takes everything off in one pass

With reservations

Some owners find the texture plain compared with luxury spa balms and miss a scent
The firm balm can feel draggy if applied to cold skin without warming first
A few owners prefer a tube or pump for hygiene over an open jar

Suits

Fragrance free loyalists, sensitive eyes, and anyone who wants a thorough balm to oil cleanse with zero scent and a completely clean rinse

Skip if

You want the sensory ritual of an aromatic spa balm, or a formula padded with treatment oils. This one is deliberately plain and functional

View on Amazon See Clinique Take The Day Off Cleansing Balm on Amazon

No. 3Best for Heavy Makeup Dayspremium tier

Farmacy Green Clean cleansing balm 100 ml white jar with green balm smear

Premium listing verified: Official Farmacy listing on Amazon with From Farmacy storefront attribution; manufacturer Farmacy Beauty as printed in the product details

Farmacy Green Clean Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm

The sorbet textured meltaway balm with a farm grown greens blend

The sorbet texture is the easiest melt in the set to work with, the spatula keeps the jar clean, and the sunflower, ginger, moringa and papaya formula is positioned squarely at waterproof makeup and SPF. For full coverage days it asks the least effort per cleanse.

The specification

Format: Sorbet texture balm in a jar, spatula included
Size: 100 ml / 3.4 fl oz
Key ingredients: Sunflower seed oil, ginger root oil, moringa seed extract, papaya fruit extract
Texture change: Balm to silky oil to milky lather
Formula note: Fresh lime and bergamot scent; not tested on animals as printed

Strengths

Sorbet like solid that melts to a silky oil and then a milky lather, with an included spatula for clean scooping
Sunflower and ginger root oils with moringa and papaya extract, a different botanical direction from the marine or floral rivals
Brand positions it against waterproof makeup and SPF, and the texture stays solid in the jar for carry on travel

Limitations

Citrus forward scent from lime, bergamot and orange peel oils, so it is not the sensitive skin pick in this set
Listing skin type field reads combination, narrower positioning than the all skin types claims of most rivals
Softer melt means warm bathrooms can leave the surface very soft in summer

What owners report

In praise

Waterproof mascara and long wear foundation coming off without tugging is the theme owners repeat most
The sorbet texture and fresh citrus scent make it a favourite among owners who find spa balms too heavy
The included spatula and the way a little spreads a long way get frequent mentions

With reservations

Citrus oils are too much for some scent sensitive owners, especially around the eyes
A few owners report needing a second cleanse for a fully squeak free finish after very heavy makeup
The jar can arrive with the balm surface melted flat after warm shipping

Suits

Full glam and waterproof mascara wearers who want a soft sorbet texture, an included spatula, and a balm the brand positions for stubborn long wear formulas

Skip if

You need a fragrance free formula. The lime, bergamot and orange oils give this jar a clear citrus scent

View on Amazon See Farmacy Green Clean Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm on Amazon

No. 4Best Unscented Luxury Balmluxury tier

Premium listing verified: Official Elemis listing on Amazon sold under Elemis USA Inc; manufacturer AmazonUs/ELNQ5 and part number EL50196 as printed in the product details, with the Naked scent variant named on the listing

Elemis Pro-Collagen Naked Cleansing Balm

The Elemis ritual with the aromatic blend taken out

Everything that makes the original Elemis formula good, with the nine essential oil blend removed. The listing names the Naked variant directly, positions it for sensitive or reactive skin, and keeps the Optimega and Padina Pavonica core intact.

The specification

Format: Solid balm in a jar
Size: 100 g / 3.5 oz
Key ingredients: Optimega oil, starflower oil, elderberry oil, Padina Pavonica, mimosa wax
Texture change: Balm to oil to cleansing milk
Formula note: Unscented Naked variant as printed; material type free reads unscented on the listing

Strengths

Same three texture transformation and core oil blend as the original, in an unscented formula as printed on the listing
Positioned by the brand for sensitive or reactive skin types in the listing copy
Retains Optimega oil, starflower oil, elderberry oil and Padina Pavonica, so the formula is not a stripped down variant

Limitations

Without the essential oil blend the experience is purely functional, closer to Clinique in spirit than to the original Elemis
Same warm transit shifting as the original, since the base texture is shared
Costs the same luxury tier as the original, so you pay full price for the quieter formula

What owners report

In praise

Owners who loved the original melt but not the scent describe this as the version they can finally use daily
Reactive skin owners praise being able to massage it over the eye area comfortably
The soft, non tight finish of the original is widely reported to carry over intact

With reservations

Some owners miss the aroma so much they return to the original and use Naked only on reactive days
A minority expected a completely neutral smell and note a faint natural oil scent from the base
Availability of the Naked variant fluctuates more than the original on Amazon

Suits

Elemis devotees with reactive or scent sensitive skin who want the same balm to oil to milk melt and the Padina Pavonica base, minus the nine essential oils

Skip if

The scent is the reason you buy Elemis. Naked deliberately removes the spa aroma that defines the original

View on Amazon See Elemis Pro-Collagen Naked Cleansing Balm on Amazon

No. 5Best Oil for Double Cleansingpremium tier

Premium listing verified: Official Dermalogica listing on Amazon under Dermalogica US with From Dermalogica storefront attribution; manufacturer Dermalogica and part number 111051 as printed in the product details

Dermalogica PreCleanse Cleansing Oil

The professional first step built for a true double cleanse

The only product here engineered as half of a system. Its apricot, kukui and borage oil blend rinses to a light milk so a second cleanser can do its work properly, which is why professionals built routines around it. Buy it as step one, never as the whole routine.

The specification

Format: Liquid cleansing oil in a pump bottle
Size: 150 ml / 5.1 fl oz
Key ingredients: Apricot kernel oil, kukui seed oil, borage seed oil, rice bran oil, vitamin E
Texture change: Oil to light milky emulsion with wet hands
Formula note: No artificial fragrance as printed; paraben free and cruelty free as printed on the listing

Strengths

Purpose built as the first half of the Dermalogica Double Cleanse, so it is formulated to rinse to a light milk and let the next cleanser reach skin
Apricot kernel, kukui and borage seed oils with rice bran and vitamin E, a lighter oil profile than the jar balms
Pump bottle dosing is fast and hygienic, and the brand directions cover eyes as well as face

Limitations

Contains citrus, lavender and lemongrass oils, so botanical oil sensitive users should patch test despite the no artificial fragrance positioning
The light texture can feel too thin for those who love a long, cushiony balm massage
Really needs the second cleanser the system assumes, which adds a step and a second product

What owners report

In praise

Owners credit it with clearing away sunscreen and sebum so their second cleanser finally feels effective
Oily skin owners like that it removes oil without leaving the pores feeling coated
The pump format and the quick, businesslike rinse come up often from routine minimalists

With reservations

Used alone it can leave a light film, which frustrates buyers who expected a standalone cleanser
The herbal citrus scent is noticeable and not for everyone
Some owners go through the bottle quickly when using it twice a day

Suits

Double cleanse devotees and oily or congestion prone skin that wants a light, fast spreading oil designed to hand over to a second cleanser

Skip if

You want a one and done cleanse with a rich finish. PreCleanse is engineered as step one and feels unfinished without the follow up wash

View on Amazon See Dermalogica PreCleanse Cleansing Oil on Amazon

No. 6Best Luxury Cleansing Oilluxury tier

Tatcha The Camellia Cleansing Oil tall white bottle with purple emblem

Premium listing verified: Official Tatcha listing on Amazon with the brand named as manufacturer and part number CC01210T as printed in the product details; Tatcha is a Luxury Stores presence on Amazon

Tatcha Pure One Step Camellia Cleansing Oil

A single step Japanese camellia oil that rinses to a milk

Japanese camellia and rice bran oils in a one to two pump routine that Tatcha positions as a genuine two in one, makeup remover and face wash together. It is the most elegant single step oil here, and the cleanest rinsing of the liquid formulas.

The specification

Format: Liquid cleansing oil in a bottle
Size: 150 ml / 5.1 fl oz
Key ingredients: Japanese camellia oil, rice bran oil, Hadasei-3 (green tea, rice and algae)
Texture change: Oil emulsifies into a milk on rinsing
Formula note: Camellia scent as printed; positioned as a two in one makeup remover and face wash

Strengths

Positioned as a two in one makeup remover and face wash, the clearest one step claim in this set
Japanese camellia oil with rice bran oil and the brand Hadasei-3 complex of green tea, rice and algae
Published routine is precise: one to two pumps on dry skin, massage, rinse with warm water as the oil turns to milk

Limitations

Fluid texture runs through fingers if you over pump, so dosing takes a night or two to learn
Camellia scent will not suit strict fragrance avoiders
Luxury tier pricing for a 150 ml bottle that daily double cleansers may finish quickly

What owners report

In praise

Owners praise how completely it rinses for an oil, leaving skin balanced rather than coated
Waterproof mascara dissolving without a separate eye makeup remover is a repeated theme
The bottle and the ritual feel are often described as the most elegant part of an evening routine

With reservations

A few owners find one step is not enough after very heavy stage or long wear makeup
The pump can dispense more than needed until you learn its measure
Some dry skin owners still prefer following with a cream cleanser in winter

Suits

Those who want an oil that behaves like a complete cleanser rather than a first step, with the elegant one to two pump routine Tatcha publishes

Skip if

You prefer a thick balm massage or a fragrance free formula. This is a fluid oil with a camellia scent profile

View on Amazon See Tatcha Pure One Step Camellia Cleansing Oil on Amazon

No. 7Best Plant Oil Blendpremium tier

Premium listing verified: Official Caudalie listing on Amazon under the CAUDALIE brand store name; manufacturer Caudalie as printed in the product details; Caudalie is a Premium Beauty presence on Amazon

Caudalie Vinoclean Makeup Removing Cleansing Oil

A 100 percent natural origin oil blend built on grape seed and almond

Three recognisable plant oils, cold pressed grape seed, organic sweet almond and castor, in a 100 percent natural origin blend that turns to a milk and needs no cotton pads. The ingredient list is the shortest story in the set, and for oil list readers that is the appeal.

The specification

Format: Liquid cleansing oil in a pump bottle
Size: 150 ml / 5 fl oz
Key ingredients: Cold pressed grape seed oil, organic sweet almond oil, castor oil
Texture change: Oil transforms into a conditioning milk with water
Formula note: Almond scent as printed; paraben free and natural material features as printed on the listing

Strengths

Cold pressed grape seed oil, organic sweet almond oil and castor oil, described by the brand as a 100 percent natural origin blend
Turns into a conditioning milk on contact with water and rinses without a greasy film, per the manufacturer directions
Works across face, eyes and lips per the brand, with a measured three pump published dose

Limitations

Almond scent is natural but present, so it sits outside the fragrance free shortlist
Thinner texture than the balms means less massage cushion on very dry skin
Castor oil richness can feel heavier around the eyes for contact lens wearers until emulsified

What owners report

In praise

Owners like the short, recognisable oil list and the absence of a synthetic feel
The quick milk transformation and clean rinse without cotton pads are praised by low waste routines
Skin feeling nourished rather than stripped is the recurring dry skin compliment

With reservations

The natural almond fragrance divides opinion, with some owners finding it too food like
Very waterproof mascara sometimes needs a second pass or a few extra seconds of massage
The pump bottle travels less securely than a solid balm jar

Suits

Buyers who read oil lists first and want a fully plant derived blend, with grape seed, sweet almond and castor oils, that turns to a milk and skips cotton pads entirely

Skip if

You dislike almond scented products or nut derived oils in your routine. The almond note is part of this formula's identity

View on Amazon See Caudalie Vinoclean Makeup Removing Cleansing Oil on Amazon

No. 8Best Ritual Balmprestige tier

Eve Lom Cleanser white jar with gold lettering and a sweep of balm

Premium listing verified: Amazon listing for the Eve Lom original balm cleanser under the EVE LOM brand name; manufacturer Eve Lom and part number CLNSR46116-100 ml as printed in the listing details; Eve Lom is a luxury boutique brand sold through Premium Beauty channels

Eve Lom Cleanser, The Original Balm Cleanser

The original balm ritual, muslin cloth and all

The founding balm still offers something none of the newer jars do: a cloth based method that adds gentle exfoliation to the cleanse, with clove, eucalyptus, hops and Egyptian chamomile oils in cocoa butter. It is the slowest cleanse here and, for its devotees, the best one.

The specification

Format: Balm cleanser in a jar, muslin cloth included
Size: 100 ml / 3.3 oz
Key ingredients: Clove oil, eucalyptus oil, hops oil, Egyptian chamomile oil, cocoa butter
Texture change: Balm worked in with massage, removed with a warm muslin cloth
Formula note: Aromatic plant oil blend; brand positions it for all skin types including sensitive

Strengths

The 5 in 1 positioning as published: cleanse, exfoliate with the cloth, tone, hydrate and remove even waterproof makeup
Aromatic plant oil blend of clove, eucalyptus, hops and Egyptian chamomile with cocoa butter, unchanged in spirit for decades
Muslin cloth included, which gives the gentle physical exfoliation the balm alone does not

Limitations

Cloth removal is part of the method, so it is the least convenient option for travel or rushed evenings
Prestige tier pricing, the highest in this set relative to jar size
The aromatic blend is strong and traditional, the opposite direction from fragrance free formulas

What owners report

In praise

Long term owners describe the massage and hot cloth sequence as the most relaxing cleanse they own
Skin looking polished and feeling conditioned after the cloth step is the signature compliment
A little goes a long way, owners often note a jar lasts far longer than expected

With reservations

The cloth routine feels like work on tired evenings, and some owners drift to simpler balms
The herbal aromatic scent is dated for some tastes and strong near the eyes
Price is the standing objection, even among fans who repurchase

Suits

Ritual devotees who want the founding balm experience, a signature massage method and a muslin cloth finish, and who treat cleansing as the main event of the evening

Skip if

You want a fast rinse and go cleanse, or you avoid aromatic oils and mineral oil based classics. This is the slowest, most ceremonial formula in the set

View on Amazon See Eve Lom Cleanser, The Original Balm Cleanser on Amazon

No. 9Best Multitasking Balmpremium tier

IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Makeup 3-in-1 cleansing balm pink jar, vitamin C and rose hip oil, 4 oz

Premium listing verified: Amazon listing under the IT Cosmetics brand storefront with the 4 oz jar actively sold on Amazon; manufacturer IT Cosmetics and model S5038600 as printed in the listing details

IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Makeup 3-in-1 Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm

The balm that also clocks in as a cleanser and a hydrating mask

Remover, cleanser and hydrating mask in one 100 g jar, with vitamin C, ceramide NP, shea butter and rosehip oil. The published ingredient list includes parfum, which keeps it off the fragrance free shortlist, but as an all rounder for normal routines it earns its place.

The specification

Format: Balm in a jar, also used as a short mask
Size: 100 g / 4 oz
Key ingredients: Vitamin C (ascorbyl palmitate), ceramide NP, shea butter, rosehip oil, jojoba seed oil
Texture change: Balm melts on contact with skin for massage, then rinses
Formula note: Contains parfum in the published ingredient list; vegan and alcohol free as described by brand aligned sources

Strengths

Genuine three way positioning as published: makeup remover, facial cleanser and hydrating facial mask in one jar
Vitamin C, ceramide NP, shea butter and rosehip oil give it the most treatment flavoured formula in this set
Brand aligned sources describe it as suitable for all skin types including sensitive, and the formula as vegan and alcohol free

Limitations

Contains parfum in the published ingredient list, which the sensitive skin shortlist must flag honestly
Vitamin C in a rinse off product has limited contact time, so treat it as a comfort ingredient rather than a brightening treatment
Softer balm texture can be scooped generously, and the 100 g jar empties faster than expected

What owners report

In praise

Owners enjoy the mask option on dry days, leaving it on while they finish an evening routine
Makeup and SPF removal in a single step, with skin feeling cushioned afterwards, is the repeated theme
The creamy melt and the jar size for the tier are often called good value by repurchasers

With reservations

The fragrance, while light to most, rules it out for strict fragrance free households
Some owners find it leaves enough comfort film that they still prefer a gentle second cleanse
The soft texture invites over scooping until you learn the dose

Suits

Multitaskers who like one jar to remove waterproof makeup and SPF, cleanse, and sit on as a short hydrating mask, with vitamin C and ceramides in the mix

Skip if

You are strictly fragrance free. The published ingredient list includes parfum, so scent sensitive buyers should choose Clinique or Elemis Naked

View on Amazon See IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Makeup 3-in-1 Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm on Amazon

No. 10Best Night Ritual Balmluxury tier

Premium listing verified: Official Estee Lauder listing on Amazon under Estee Lauder Inc. with From Estee Lauder storefront attribution, as seen on the live listing

Estee Lauder Advanced Night Cleansing Balm

A buttery night balm with a 25 percent safflower oil infusion

A buttery, cocooning balm with a stated 25 percent safflower seed oil infusion that arcs from balm to oil to cushioning milk. The 2.2 fl oz jar makes it a treat rather than a workhorse, but the texture work is the most refined in the set.

The specification

Format: Buttery balm in a jar
Size: 2.2 fl oz
Key ingredients: Safflower seed oil (25 percent lipid rich oil infusion), algae extract, chamomile, lavender
Texture change: Balm to delicate oil to cushioning milk
Formula note: Oil based makeup remover positioned by the brand to work without stripping skin or disturbing the moisture barrier

Strengths

Lipid rich oil infusion with 25 percent safflower seed oil, the most precisely quantified oil content in this set
Three texture arc as published: buttery balm, delicate cleansing oil, then a cushioning milk that washes away without residue
Brand positions it for long wear and waterproof face, eye and lip makeup plus sunscreen, used nightly on dry skin

Limitations

Smallest jar in the set at 2.2 fl oz, so it is a step up treat rather than a workhorse
Formula includes lavender and chamomile elements and fragrance components in the published list, so it is not a fragrance free pick
Night only positioning in the brand directions, though nothing stops a morning use beyond the ritual framing

What owners report

In praise

Owners describe the texture as the most buttery of the balms they have tried, with a cocooning feel
Skin feeling soft, smooth and nourished after rinsing is the dominant theme in owner commentary the brand summarises
The gold lidded jar and the night ritual branding make it a gift favourite

With reservations

Jar size is the standing complaint, owners wish for a larger format at this tier
Richness can feel like more than oily skin wants in warm weather
Some owners prefer a spatula for the soft butter texture and note none is emphasised in the listing

Suits

Night routine loyalists who want a buttery balm that turns to oil and then a cushioning milk, built to lift long wear and waterproof makeup, sunscreen and the day's residue

Skip if

You want a big jar. At 2.2 fl oz this is the smallest full size in the set, and heavy daily users will feel the cost per cleanse

View on Amazon See Estee Lauder Advanced Night Cleansing Balm on Amazon

No. 3

Side by Side

The published specifications that separate the ranking.

Product	Format	Size	Key ingredients	Texture change
Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm	Solid balm in a jar	100 g / 3.5 oz	Padina Pavonica, starflower oil, elderberry oil, Optimega oil, rose and mimosa waxes	Balm to oil to cleansing milk
Clinique Take The Day Off Cleansing Balm	Solid balm in a jar	125 ml / 3.8 oz	Safflower seed oil, caprylic/capric triglyceride, tocopherol	Solid balm to silky oil
Farmacy Green Clean Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm	Sorbet texture balm in a jar, spatula included	100 ml / 3.4 fl oz	Sunflower seed oil, ginger root oil, moringa seed extract, papaya fruit extract	Balm to silky oil to milky lather
Elemis Pro-Collagen Naked Cleansing Balm	Solid balm in a jar	100 g / 3.5 oz	Optimega oil, starflower oil, elderberry oil, Padina Pavonica, mimosa wax	Balm to oil to cleansing milk
Dermalogica PreCleanse Cleansing Oil	Liquid cleansing oil in a pump bottle	150 ml / 5.1 fl oz	Apricot kernel oil, kukui seed oil, borage seed oil, rice bran oil, vitamin E	Oil to light milky emulsion with wet hands
Tatcha Pure One Step Camellia Cleansing Oil	Liquid cleansing oil in a bottle	150 ml / 5.1 fl oz	Japanese camellia oil, rice bran oil, Hadasei-3 (green tea, rice and algae)	Oil emulsifies into a milk on rinsing
Caudalie Vinoclean Makeup Removing Cleansing Oil	Liquid cleansing oil in a pump bottle	150 ml / 5 fl oz	Cold pressed grape seed oil, organic sweet almond oil, castor oil	Oil transforms into a conditioning milk with water
Eve Lom Cleanser, The Original Balm Cleanser	Balm cleanser in a jar, muslin cloth included	100 ml / 3.3 oz	Clove oil, eucalyptus oil, hops oil, Egyptian chamomile oil, cocoa butter	Balm worked in with massage, removed with a warm muslin cloth
IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Makeup 3-in-1 Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm	Balm in a jar, also used as a short mask	100 g / 4 oz	Vitamin C (ascorbyl palmitate), ceramide NP, shea butter, rosehip oil, jojoba seed oil	Balm melts on contact with skin for massage, then rinses
Estee Lauder Advanced Night Cleansing Balm	Buttery balm in a jar	2.2 fl oz	Safflower seed oil (25 percent lipid rich oil infusion), algae extract, chamomile, lavender	Balm to delicate oil to cushioning milk

No. 4

How We Chose

The four measures behind this ranking.

Measure 1

Verified premium listings only

Every product was checked on its live Amazon listing for the brand storefront signal, the manufacturer as printed, and availability. Anything that could not be confirmed as a genuine premium listing, including one well known balm whose Amazon presence could not be verified to that standard, was replaced with a verified alternative. For the 2027 ranking, that verification was the entry ticket, not a bonus.

Measure 2

Melt and rinse behaviour

A first cleanser lives or dies on two moments: how completely it dissolves makeup and sunscreen during the massage, and how cleanly it leaves the skin afterwards. We weighted published texture behaviour, balm to oil to milk or oil to emulsion, and the removal claims each brand actually prints.

Measure 3

Fragrance honesty

This category splits sharply on scent, so we recorded fragrance status from the listings and ingredient lists rather than marketing language. Fragrance free, unscented, naturally scented and perfumed formulas are labelled as what they are, because sensitive skin buyers cannot afford surprises.

Measure 4

Format fit for real routines

Jar balms, pump oils, cloth methods and mask capable formulas suit different evenings. We ranked with routine fit in mind, travel, double cleansing, speed, and how much ceremony each product asks for, instead of pretending one format wins for everyone.

No. 5

Questions, Answered

Do I still need a second cleanser after a balm or oil?

It depends on the product and your skin. Oils designed as step one, like Dermalogica PreCleanse, assume a follow up cleanser and can leave a light film alone. One step positioned oils and most balms, used with enough massage and a thorough rinse, are enough for many people on light makeup days. If you wear heavy sunscreen or long wear foundation, a gentle second cleanse is the reliable route.

What is the difference between a cleansing balm and a cleansing oil?

Texture and handling, mostly. A balm is a solid oil blend in a jar that melts on skin, travels without leaking, and suits a slower massage. A cleansing oil is the same idea in liquid form, dosed by pump, faster to spread and usually lighter rinsing. Both dissolve makeup and sunscreen the same way, and our oils versus balms guide walks through the trade offs in detail.

Which of these are genuinely fragrance free?

Clinique Take The Day Off is published as 100 percent fragrance free, and the Elemis Pro-Collagen Naked balm is the unscented variant of the original. Dermalogica PreCleanse is printed as no artificial fragrance, though it contains botanical oils. The IT Cosmetics balm contains parfum in its published ingredient list, and the original Elemis, Eve Lom, Farmacy, Tatcha, Caudalie and Estee Lauder formulas are all scented to different degrees.

Can cleansing balms remove waterproof mascara?

Yes, that is the job they are built for, and several brands here publish removal claims for waterproof formulas. The technique matters: massage over dry lashes for a full minute, give the oils time to dissolve the mascara, then emulsify with wet fingertips before rinsing. Rubbing harder is never the answer, more time is.

Is this ranking the 2027 edition?

Yes. These are the versions verified on their live Amazon listings as the 2027 edition was prepared, judged on melt, rinse and the fragrance status printed on each listing. First cleansers change slowly compared with serums, which is why this ranking leans on format and formula honesty, the two things a 2027 relaunch rarely improves.

No. ·

Keep Researching

Every page in the Cleansing Balms and Makeup Removers edit.

No. ·

More from the Moisturize and Cleanse Desk

Moisturize and Cleanse

Eye Creams

Creams, gels and one honest temporary tightener for the eye contour, ranked by format and formula

Read the edit

Moisturize and Cleanse

Face Cleansers

Premium gels, creams, foams and powders, matched to how your skin actually behaves at the sink

Read the edit

Moisturize and Cleanse

Face Moisturizers

Eleven premium creams, sorted by texture first and by skin behaviour second

Read the edit

Best eye creams Best face cleansers Best face moisturizers All moisturize and cleanse coverage

Disclosure: links on this page are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Eclat Press earns from qualifying purchases, at no added cost to you. Rankings are never sold. See our affiliate disclosure and methodology.