Premium BeautyEst. 2026
Eclat Press

The Premium Beauty Edit

Focused Guide · The balm wardrobe compared honestly: a shared base acknowledged up front, then the real differences of scent, lead oils and skin fit that should decide the purchase.

Elemis Cleansing Balms Compared: Original, Naked and Rose

Three jars, one balm base, three scents and three skin moods. A close comparison of the Elemis cleansing balm wardrobe to help you buy exactly one, correctly.

Elemis Cleansing Balms Compared: Original, Naked and Rose - the Eclat Press editorial plate
Elemis Cleansing Balms Compared: Original, Naked and RoseFocused Guide
No. 1

The Selection

3 listings that answer this brief.

Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm 100g open jar showing the yellow balm
No. 1

Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm 100g

The Original Ritual

The original balm, oil and milk cleanser in one jar

Nine essential oils including lavender, chamomile and eucalyptus make this the full spa performance, with rose and mimosa waxes in the base. Buy it for the experience as much as the cleanse.

Suits

Anyone whose evening cleanse has to remove a full face of makeup and still feel like the best part of the routine

Skip if

You dislike scented skincare or want a cleanser that foams under the tap and rinses in seconds

Size
100g jar
Format
Balm to oil to milk cleansing balm
Key ingredients
Padina Pavonica, starflower oil, elderberry oil, rose and mimosa waxes
Use
Massage over dry skin, moisten fingertips, remove with a warm cloth; also a 10 minute mask
Range
Pro-Collagen
View on AmazonPremium listing verified: Amazon.com listing under the ELEMIS Skincare storefront; the house's No.1 best seller as printed in the listing description
Elemis Pro-Collagen Naked Cleansing Balm 100g jar with silver lid
No. 2

Elemis Pro-Collagen Naked Cleansing Balm 100g

The Sensitive Skin Pick

The same balm ritual with the fragrance taken out

The fragrance free edition, leading with Optimega oil and printed for sensitive or reactive skin. It keeps the makeup removal and drops the aromatherapy, which for many faces is the correct trade.

Suits

Sensitive or reactive skin, and anyone who loved the balm idea but not the spa scent

Skip if

The aromatic ritual is exactly why you buy Elemis, in which case the original is your jar

Size
100g jar
Format
Fragrance free balm to oil to milk cleanser
Key ingredients
Optimega oil, starflower oil, elderberry oil, Padina Pavonica
Use
Massage over dry skin, add warm water to emulsify, remove with a warm cloth
Range
Pro-Collagen
View on AmazonPremium listing verified: Official Elemis listing on Amazon.com; manufacturer printed as AmazonUs/ELNQ5 in the product details, scent name printed as Naked
Elemis Pro-Collagen Rose Cleansing Balm pink 100g jar with silver lid
No. 3

Elemis Pro-Collagen Rose Cleansing Balm 100g

The Soothing Pick

The balm reworked around English rose for a calmer cleanse

English Rose Oleo Extract turns the same cleanse floral and calming in framing. It is the evening, wind down jar of the three.

Suits

Rose lovers and skin that flushes easily, who want the balm cleanse framed as soothing rather than invigorating

Skip if

Floral scents are not your taste, or you need the fragrance free version

Size
100g jar
Format
Balm to oil to milk cleansing balm, rose variant
Key ingredients
English Rose Oleo Extract, Padina Pavonica, elderberry oil, rose wax
Use
Massage over dry skin, moisten fingertips, remove with a warm cloth
Range
Pro-Collagen
View on AmazonPremium listing verified: Amazon.com listing for the Rose variant of the Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm under the ELEMIS brand; scent printed as Rose in the listing options
No. 2

Questions, Answered

Does the Naked balm remove makeup as well as the original?

By the printed formula, yes. It keeps the balm to oil to milk structure and the cleansing oils, swapping the aromatic blend for an Optimega led, fragrance free base. Owners consistently describe the makeup removal as equal; what changes is the scent and the skin fit.

Why does my balm arrive looking half melted or uneven?

The brand addresses this directly in the listing: the formula has a low melting point, shifts in warm transit and may reset unevenly with oil on the surface. Elemis states this does not affect the quantity or quality. Store the jar somewhere cool and it will firm back up.

Widen the lens in the full Best Elemis Products 2027: The House Ranked Against Itself ranking, or return to the Elemis hub.

No. ·

Keep Researching

Every page in the Elemis edit.

  1. 01Elemis: the hubHub
  2. 02Best Elemis Products 2027: The House Ranked Against ItselfBest of
  3. 03The Elemis Pro-Collagen Line, Read CloselyGuide
  4. 04Elemis for Dry Skin: The Richest Formulas in the LineGuide
  5. 05Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm Review: The Jar the Brand Stands OnReview
  6. 06Elemis Pro-Collagen Marine Cream Review: A Light Gel-Cream With a Heavy ReputationReview
  7. 07Elemis Pro-Collagen Future Restore Serum Review: The Line Grows a Concentrated StepReview
  8. 08Elemis Cleansing Balm vs Marine Cream: Cleanse or Cream First?Comparison
  9. 09Elemis Eye Revive Mask vs Vitality Eye Cream: Mask or Daily Cream?Comparison
  10. 10Elemis Buying Guide: How to Build an Elemis Shelf Without DuplicatesBuying guide
  11. 11Elemis Care and Keeping: Balms, Jars and Rituals Done RightCare
No. ·

More from the The Houses Desk

The Houses

Caudalie

The Bordeaux vine house, read through Viniferine, Resveratrol and grape water

Read the edit

The Houses

Dermalogica

The professional, education led house, read by ritual step

Read the edit

The Houses

Peter Thomas Roth

The results led New York house, organised by its named lines

Read the edit

Best caudalieBest dermalogicaBest peter thomas rothAll the houses coverage

Disclosure: links on this page are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Eclat Press earns from qualifying purchases, at no added cost to you. Rankings are never sold. See our affiliate disclosure and methodology.