Head to Head
Living Proof Advanced Clean vs Klorane Oat+ Dry Shampoo
Prestige aerosol against pharmacy classic: depth of cleanse, finish, ritual and routine fit, compared from the published formulas of both.
Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Advanced Clean Dry Shampoo
The dry shampoo positioned as a rinse out clean, with conditioned ends.
Klorane Ultra Gentle Dry Shampoo with Oat+
The French pharmacy original, rebuilt around oat and natural powders.
Where They Differ
Depth of cleanse
Advanced Clean pairs rice and corn starch with cyclodextrin and a conditioning system, and positions itself as rivalling a rinse out shampoo. Klorane's starch pair with oat sprout oil is aimed at a 12 hour plus refresh in the brand's own testing. One is a substitute wash, the other is a top up, and choosing between them is mostly choosing which of those jobs you actually have.
Finish and feel
Living Proof is built to disappear into softness and shine, silicone free and colour safe, with no styling texture added. Klorane restores volume and texture with a powder light feel that some owners read as grip. Hair that hates product feel prefers Living Proof; hair that wants day two body prefers Klorane.
Ritual and routine
Advanced Clean demands the full shake, distance, 30 second wait and massage out, and punishes shortcuts with visible powder. Klorane is forgiving: spray, brief pause, brush. The Klorane can is also half the size, 3.2 oz against 5.5 oz, which matters to daily users doing cost per month maths rather than cost per can.
The Specification, Side by Side
| Measure | Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Advanced Clean Dry Shampoo | Klorane Ultra Gentle Dry Shampoo with Oat+ |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 5.5 fl oz (184 ml) aerosol can | 3.2 oz (150 ml) aerosol can |
| Format | Aerosol spray | Aerosol spray |
| Key absorbent | Rice starch and corn starch, as printed in the ingredient list | Rice starch and corn starch with oat sprout oil, as printed in the ingredient list |
| Hair types | All hair types, including fine and curly hair, as published | All hair types, as printed on the can |
| Scent | Light citrus, as published | Not published |
| Formula notes | Not published | Hypoallergenic and vegan; paraben free and sulfate free, as published |
Choose Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Advanced Clean Dry Shampoo if
- Your non wash days need to be indistinguishable from wash days
- You dislike gritty or texturised finishes and want softness and shine
- You are willing to follow a precise application ritual every time
Choose Klorane Ultra Gentle Dry Shampoo with Oat+ if
- You refresh frequently and wash frequently, and want the gentlest formula
- You want a fast, forgiving spray with no technique to learn
- You prefer a hypoallergenic, vegan, pharmacy heritage formula
Questions, Answered
Which is better on dark hair?
Neither is tinted, so both ask for technique. Advanced Clean goes on white by design and clears fully with its wait and massage routine, and dark haired owners report a clean finish when the steps are followed. Klorane's finer powder is less visible but can show a cast if rushed. If white cast is your deciding issue, the tinted picks in this topic, Moroccanoil Dark Tones and Klorane Nettle Tint, exist precisely to remove the question.
Keep Researching
Every page in the Dry Shampoos edit.
- 01Dry Shampoos: the hubHub
- 02Best Dry Shampoos 2027Best of
- 03How to Apply Dry Shampoo ProperlyGuide
- 04Dry Shampoo for Dark HairGuide
- 05Dry Shampoo vs Washing: How Many Days It Can BridgeGuide
- 06Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Advanced Clean Dry Shampoo ReviewReview
- 07Klorane Ultra Gentle Dry Shampoo with Oat+ ReviewReview
- 08Amika Perk Up Plus Extended Clean Dry Shampoo ReviewReview
- 09Briogeo Charcoal Powder vs IGK First Class: Powder vs AerosolComparison
- 10Dry Shampoo Buying GuideBuying guide
- 11Dry Shampoo Mistakes and Fixes: White Cast, Grit and BuildupCare
More from the Premium Hair Desk
Premium Hair
Bond Repair and Hair Treatments
Bond repair treatments sorted by technology, format and the damage pattern they actually suit
Read the edit
Premium Hair
Clarifying and Sulfate-Free Shampoos
Two different wash jobs, kept separate: deep cleansing clarifiers for build-up days, and gentle sulfate-free shampoos for every other day
Read the edit
Premium Hair
Hair Gloss and Shine Treatments
Premium hair glosses judged on clear versus tinted colour effect, time in the hair and how long the shine is published to last.
Read the edit
Disclosure: links on this page are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Eclat Press earns from qualifying purchases, at no added cost to you. Rankings are never sold. See our affiliate disclosure and methodology.